Welcome to Liverpool Confidential
Reset Password
The Confidential websites will be undergoing routine updates. This may cause the sites to go offline. We apologise in advance for any inconvenience.

You are here: Liverpool ConfidentialEntertainmentTV & Film Reviews.

Public Enemies (15)

Is Johnny Depp a fop or a flop? Lew Baxter decides

Published on July 8th 2009.

Public Enemies (15)

IF you are inclined to the modern liberal stance, the one which detests the glorification of ruthless hoodlums, then prepare to wince at this elegantly composed herogram to the US Depression era bank robber, John Dillinger.

Mann should really have had a quiet word with Depp and asked him to pitch in a bit more snarling and grunting, rather than allowing him to generally sashay about cutting fine dashes and wooing his moll

Catcalls are for the apparent good guys, led by Christian Bale, alias FBI agent Melvin Purvis, whose specially chosen squad of cops is as chillingly murderous in its own way as the buckaroos they are pursuing.

Perhaps it's that Johnny Depp, as gimlet-eyed killer Dillinger, cuts a more romantic, even glamorous, kind of figure than Bale who, once again, is verging on the one dimensional; barely displaying any real emotion or facial movement.

Depp seems to have figured that Dillinger needs to come across as a carefree, folksy kind of bandit who indifferently outwits his nemesis until, quite cheesed off at his sheer, brazen nerve, Purvis turns on the heat, good style.

In reality, Dillinger is a thug with a genial smile and a winning way with words - there are several glorious slabs of dialogue - whose only loyalty is to his pals (and that’s not fully a given) and his squeeze, former cloakroom attendant Billie.

He lives life to the full and on the hog at swish restaurants while, despite his freebooting antics, wallowing in the benediction of the masses who are - just like now, girls and boys - enraged by the greed of bankers.

Where director Michael Mann clearly get his own rocks off is in the action sequences: unleashing gunslinging fire fights on a grand scale as the lads on either side empty their ‘tommy’ guns and pistols at will, at random, and very loudly – at anyone in their way.

It is a beautifully - excuse me – shot piece of work, in high definition digital, well crafted and paced, although Mann should really have had a quiet word with Depp and asked him to pitch in a bit more snarling and grunting, rather than allowing him to generally sashay about cutting fine dashes and wooing his moll.

And here we are talking a truly sparkling performance from the French actress Marion Cotillard who comes within a sultry silk stocking of stealing the show from under the twitchy noses of Bale and Depp.

Mind you Depp does make a fair fist of leaping onto bank counters and ordering terrified folk to lie down and shut up, blah, blah, while he and his henchmen make off with the loot.

He also has this irritating trait of grabbing a couple of them as hostages to cover the gang’s getaway, but usually lets them go after a couple of criminal flavoured bon mots are delivered their way.

The movie starts with what appears to be Dillinger in cuffs on his way to the State Penitentiary. In fact, it’s a prison break-out, as he needs the boys out and about to continue their crime sprees.

It’s deftly orchestrated until one of the chums goes haywire and shoots a guard – and thus do the thrills and spills commence.

Purvis – with the support of new FBI director J Edgar Hoover – brings in a posse of tough nut G-men and it's time to lay waste to Dillinger’s motley bunch, eventually with the collusion of The Mob who are nervous his escapades will attract attention to their own little scams.

It’s all based on a factual book about gangsters by Brian Burroughs and adapted by Mann for the screen, like he did with the first Hannibal Lecter film, Manhunter, and then James Fenimore Cooper’s Last of the Mohicans, in 1992, which was a blockbuster of an effort.

In truth, Mann was better served by Tom Cruise as the brutal, non-smiling, cold hit man in Collateral than he is by Depp here ( and at that admission this critic is choking on chunks of humble pie, being of the personal conviction that most of the ‘classy’ movies starring Cruise, particularly, Last Samurai and War of the Worlds, could have been listed amongst the cinema greats of all time if he hadn’t been in them).

No matter a few foibles, Public Enemies is a great yarn - and the ‘lightness of being’ of Depp not withstanding - it will surely be acknowledged in time as one of the more intellectual of the gangster chase genre: up there with Heat and The Untouchables – honest.

8/10 – Enthralling and intoxicating. Now on general release

Like what you see? Enter your email to sign up for our newsletters which are chock-a-block with more great reviews, news, deals and savings.

5 comments so far, continue the conversation, write a comment.

KIDNEY STONEJuly 6th 2009.

Depp proves yet again that he cant act (that is unless acting comprises pouting,pulling faces, and walking in a strange way).Bruce willis would have been a better Dillinger. Lee Marvin the best of all if he had lived.

Tommy-Gun NelsonJuly 6th 2009.

Anonymous. Matt. Take it outside or we'll have to call the F.B. Aiiiye!!!

MattJuly 6th 2009.

The film is not 'average'. It is very very good. Depp is a vision, as is his moll, who any self-respecting bloke would willingly rob a few banks for.

DigJuly 6th 2009.

Here we go! Not seen the film yet but I'm disappointed there isn't one mention of Liverpools own Stephen 'Dutchie' Graham in the review. My old mate and Kirkby lad mixing it with the likes of Depp et al. I know he's been mixing with the big Hollywood boys for a while but he deserves a mention considering it's a Liverpool website. Well, I guess I've mentioned him instead now. By the way, what does Tamar mean Ed?

AnonymousJuly 6th 2009.

I felt the film was quite average. The action scenes where good, but even they looked odd as the image quality of the film suddenly becomes very 'digital tv like' at those points. 5/10

To post this comment, you need to login.Please complete your login information.
Or you can login using Facebook.

Latest Rants


You should have seen Frank Sidebottom when he played The Zanzibar. Great days.

 Read more

Not THAT Jon Ronson surely? The pseudo-American twerp from Swansea with the mystifyingly successful…

 Read more
Judith Patterson

If she was that good, why wasn't she taken on?

 Read more
Eddie Miles

We went to the Cavern Club and the Epstein Theatre productions and thought they were both…

 Read more

Explore The Site

© Mark Garner t/a Confidential Direct 2022

Privacy | Careers | Website by: Planet Code