Welcome to Liverpool Confidential
Reset Password
The Confidential websites will be undergoing routine updates. This may cause the sites to go offline. We apologise in advance for any inconvenience.

You are here: Liverpool ConfidentialEntertainmentMusic.

Vinyl will last forever

Spotify may have changed its T&Cs, but nobody would miss it, argues Penny Kiley

Written by . Published on October 3rd 2011.

Vinyl will last forever

WHENEVER I go on Facebook the "top news" at any given time is a whole load of YouTube videos.

Spotify-030I wonder if it's my demographic or just the sort of people I know. It might be interesting to see a typical timeline for people of different ages. Babies? Politics? Misspelled incomprehensible stuff?

Sometimes I think that it's all a bit like writing the name of bands on your satchel. We all know we all like the Clash, Mott the Hoople and Bob Dylan so why do we have to tell each other about it?

But sometimes it's nice to be told about something I don't know. Like the link to Spotify of the Ramones doing My Back Pages. 

That's what sharing is all about. Or it is now?

I laughed a lot at the panic emanating from younger people when Spotify changed their terms and conditions. When I suggested that there might be an alternative they complained about (1) the clutter of physical media and (2) having to part with hard cash. 

In the olden days there was something called vinyl. And those were two of its USPs.

If you wanted a night out, you'd all go
round someone's house and listen to records.
In the same room. Not stuck at the end
of several different computers

The whole point of a vinyl record was that it wasn't just about the music. It was a physical object. Or 'artefact' as we liked to say, pretentiously. Records had weight (well at least until the oil shortage some time in the 1970s, after which they all got a bit bendy). And they had area: 12 inches square of album cover for art, photos, sleevenotes and what we pretentiously liked to call 'lyrics' (it was a pretentious era). You could listen to the music and read the words. You could listen to the music and read about who played the music or look at pictures of the people who made the music. It was a total package. Virtual music just isn't the same. 

Having to part with cash - was that a selling point? In a way it was. Because if you couldn't have access to everything, then you valued what you had. For years I only ever bought LPs at Christmas and birthdays - pocket money only stretched to singles. And I played those singles over and over again. Including the B sides.

I laughed, too, when someone expressed the fear that if everyone stopped using Spotify they wouldn't be able to 'find music via people' any more.

Once, our whole social life revolved around 'finding music via people'. You had to track down good music: there were only a few TV and radio shows where you could discover the good stuff. Or record shop booths for as long as it took before they sussed that you weren't buying and kicked you out.

Cd_StackCDs have bad press
stacked against them
So if you knew someone who owned a record that you didn't have, you'd borrow it. If you wanted to be friends with someone, you'd offer to lend them a record. If you wanted a night out, you'd all go round someone's house and listen to records. In the same room. Not stuck at the end of several different computers. 

They tried to kill vinyl. I own a lot of CDs but they're not the same. When they skip, which they do a lot, I hate them. Just another 1980s con like royal weddings, new romantics and Walkmans. You can't love a CD and it doesn't even last. 

Vinyl records last (as long as you don't put them anywhere hot). And in the low-carbon post-peak-oil future we'll still be able to use them even without electricity. As long as there's still a wind-up gramophone somewhere. And as long as it doesn't just play 78s.

No-one will miss CDs. No-one will remember Spotify. But vinyl will last for ever.

*Penny Kiley is a former national music journalist who operated out of Liverpool for many years. Her blog, Older Than Elvis, is here

Like what you see? Enter your email to sign up for our newsletters which are chock-a-block with more great reviews, news, deals and savings.

DJ DANOctober 3rd 2011.

You're right about CD's, but you miss a very important point about spotify: With Spotify I can play almost any tune, from anywhere with an internet connection, whenever I want. Absorb that for a second, because it's mind blowing.

I had a whole four more paragraphs but it failed to post and I can't remember what else I wrote, it pretty much concentrated on you harking back to a long forgotten age that won't ever return. Physical media (including vinyl) is dead. Just wait and see.

GrooverOctober 4th 2011.

Isn't all recorded music dead, DJ Dan? Some would say it stopped being interesting when it stopped being a tangible, black 12 inch commodity (missus).

AnonymousOctober 4th 2011.

There's ace music I have discovered on spotify that I would never have come across if it had been on CD in a shop. CDs cheapened pop music and now nobody is prepared anything for it. And so pop has eaten itself

To post this comment, you need to login.Please complete your login information.
Or you can login using Facebook.

Latest Rants


How No Guarantor Loans Help in Availing Credible Finance? Jul 10, 2017 - No guarantor loans help…

 Read more
David St Hubbins

Great drawing, love the mini Stonehenge.

 Read more
John Bradley

Julian Cope the real thing compared with his halfwitted ex-associate and professional scouser Pete…

 Read more

They make a lovely SOUP, even when they end up like the so called performer........WASHED UP!!!!…

 Read more

Explore The Site

© Mark Garner t/a Confidential Direct 2022

Privacy | Careers | Website by: Planet Code